San Jose Earthquakes 1–3 St. Louis City: AI predicted 1–1 ✗
What did the AI predict for San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City?
ScoreGPT's AI panel predicted San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City (MLS) at a 1–1 consensus scoreline, with 3 of 5 models backing San Jose Earthquakes. The final result and grade are below — information only, not betting advice.
Every pick is graded after full time — see how our grading works and the live AI model leaderboard.
What you get in the app
Every model's reasoning — not just the score
See all model picks, the full breakdown, and how each one performed — free.
the app
The AI verdict
San Jose Earthquakes are the slight favorites, largely because St. Louis City will be missing their key creator Marcel Hartel, who just transferred away. However, San Jose's own defensive issues and St. Louis's strong form make this a close match.
ScoreGPT predicted a win for San Jose Earthquakes — final score San Jose Earthquakes 1–3 St. Louis City. Wrong, and it counts on the public record.
- San Jose have lost four of their last six matches, conceding 16 goals in that span.
- St. Louis City are unbeaten in nine matches, with the third-best goal differential in MLS over that period.
- St. Louis City will be without Marcel Hartel, who had six goals and three assists this season, after his transfer to Hannover 96.
- San Jose are missing their top creator Niko Tsakiris, who has been out since May with a groin injury.
- San Jose won the last head-to-head meeting in April, with Timo Werner scoring twice.
AI analysis generated 2026-08-15
Why ScoreGPT's AI panel leaned this way — San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City
- San Jose defensive collapse (16 GA in 6)
- Hartel departure guts St. Louis creativity
- Both teams missing primary creative hubs
- St. Louis unbeaten in nine, strong away
From ScoreGPT's pre-match AI analysis of San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City, written before kickoff on 16 August 2026:
A close call where stale pricing meets genuine uncertainty
Five models split 3-2 on the result, but the disagreement is narrower than it looks: all five see a tight, low-scoring match decided by one goal, and all five identify the same two tensions — San Jose's defensive collapse versus St. Louis's sudden loss of Marcel Hartel. The resolution comes down to which factor matters more in this specific fixture.
The case for San Jose: Hartel's departure creates an immediate creative void
Three models (Claude, GPT, Grok) back San Jose, and their strongest shared argument is that Hartel's transfer to Hannover 96 on August 11 removes St. Louis's primary chance creator at the worst possible time. Hartel had six goals and three assists in 1,346 minutes, 44 chances created, and seven goal contributions in his final five appearances. His replacement, Carlo Holse, only recently arrived from Samsunspor and has had minimal time to integrate into Yoann Damet's system. In the first match without a player who connected possession structure to final-third decisions, St. Louis's attacking output should drop sharply.
San Jose still has Timo Werner and Preston Judd, who have 11 goals between them and provide a direct threat regardless of who creates behind them. Werner scored twice in the 3-2 win at St. Louis in April, and Judd's physical presence gives San Jose a route around CITY's three-center-back structure. The 14-day break since their last match also gives Bruce Arena time to address the defensive issues that have plagued them since the World Cup hiatus.
The model panel — graded: San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City
MLS · 16 August 2026 · scorelines read San Jose Earthquakes–St. Louis City
Every pick, graded on the final result: San Jose Earthquakes 1–3 St. Louis City.
Frequently asked
▸Who did the AI predict to win San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City?
3 of 5 AI models analyzed by ScoreGPT predicted San Jose Earthquakes to win before kickoff. The match finished San Jose Earthquakes 1–3 St. Louis City, so the consensus pick was wrong — and it stays on the public record either way.
▸What score did the AI predict for San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City?
ScoreGPT's averaged AI scoreline was San Jose Earthquakes 1–1 St. Louis City. The actual final score was San Jose Earthquakes 1–3 St. Louis City.
▸How does ScoreGPT make MLS predictions?
Multiple AI models independently analyze form, squads and match context for every covered MLS fixture. ScoreGPT compares their picks and grades every prediction publicly after the final whistle.
▸Which AI models have predicted San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City?
5 AI models predicted this match, each graded on the final result: GPT-5.6 1–0 (✗ wrong result); Claude Opus 5 2–1 (✗ wrong result); Grok 4.6 2–1 (✗ wrong result); Kimi K3 1–2 (✓ correct result); GLM-5.2 1–2 (✓ correct result). Every pick is graded publicly after full time.
▸What are the key factors for San Jose Earthquakes vs St. Louis City?
Key factors include San Jose's defensive collapse, having conceded 16 goals in their last six matches, and St. Louis's impressive unbeaten streak of nine games. Additionally, both teams are missing their primary creative players: St. Louis without Marcel Hartel and San Jose without Niko Tsakiris. These absences could level the playing field.
More MLS predictions
Recent MLS results — graded
AI predictions are for information and entertainment only — not betting advice. 18+. Please gamble responsibly.