Everton vs Newcastle prediction: 4 of 5 AI models back Newcastle
1–2
AI consensus
A win for Newcastle4/5 back Newcastle
Agreement is a model vote, not a probability.
Hill Dickinson Stadium, Liverpool
Carabao Cup ·
Updated · ScoreGPT multi-model panel
3 free AI predictions every week — no sign-up.
The model panel: Everton vs Newcastle
Carabao Cup · 29 October 2026 · scorelines read Everton–Newcastle
- GPT-6.1 SolLeans Newcastle0–1Market pick in app
- Claude Opus 5.5Leans Newcastle1–2Market pick in app
- Grok 4.7Leans Newcastleexact score in appMarket pick in app
- DeepSeek-V4-ProLeans Newcastleexact score in appMarket pick in app
- Kimi K3.1 ProLeans Evertonexact score in appMarket pick in app
Each model may also pick one match market — 1X2, over/under 2.5 goals or both teams to score — and every pick is graded. In the app.
Download the free app
3 free AI predictions every week — no sign-up.
What does the AI predict for Everton vs Newcastle?
As of 29 October 2026, for Everton vs Newcastle (Carabao Cup), ScoreGPT's AI panel reached a 1–2 consensus scoreline, with 4 of 5 models picking Newcastle. Key factors: Everton's thin, injury-hit squad; Newcastle committing a strong XI. Every pick is graded publicly after full-time — for information and entertainment only.
Every pick is graded after full time — see how our grading works and the live AI model leaderboard.
The AI verdict
Newcastle are the narrow lean, based on Everton's injury-hit squad and blunt attack against a Newcastle side promising a strong XI. The margin is thin, with a level game a real possibility.
- Everton are without several key players, with Branthwaite, Grealish and Mykolenko all doubtful and full-backs possibly out of position.
- Everton have scored only five goals in their last six matches and lost their two most recent games without scoring.
- Newcastle boss Jaissle has promised a strong side after a win at Palace, though his defence has been fragile.
- Newcastle lost heavily at Leeds and Coventry recently, so one clean sheet does not resolve their defensive volatility.
- Four of the five panel models lean Newcastle, but only by thin margins, with plenty of weight on a draw.
AI analysis generated 2026-10-28
Why ScoreGPT's AI panel leans this way — Everton vs Newcastle
- Everton's thin, injury-hit squad
- Newcastle committing a strong XI
- Everton's blunt recent attack
- Newcastle's defensive volatility
Synthesis
Four of the five models lean Newcastle, but by thin margins. The fixed result is therefore a narrow away win, with a lot of weight on a level game.
Where the experts agree
- Everton are short of bodies. Branthwaite (concussion protocol), Grealish (illness) and Mykolenko (knock at Arsenal) are all doubtful. Garner and Röhl may have to play out of position at full-back.
- Everton are not scoring. They have lost 0-2 to both Chelsea and Arsenal and have scored only 5 goals in their last 6.
- Newcastle say they are going all in. Jaissle has promised a strong side after the 2-0 win at Palace.
- Newcastle are defensively fragile. They lost 1-4 at both Leeds and Coventry, and one clean sheet does not fix that.
Where they disagree, and how I resolved it
Kimi alone backs Everton. Its case rests on Newcastle's shorter rest (about 102 hours against 126), planned rotation and a long absentee list. Those points are real, but Jaissle's public commitment to a strong XI and Newcastle's depth in attack (Barnes, Osula, Wissa) weaken the rotation argument. Everton's blunt attack and makeshift defence also count against a home win. I give Kimi's view some weight, which is why the margin is thin. I do not treat Everton's depleted squad as decisive. Their injury list is still unconfirmed, and Moyes' sides are hard to beat at home.
Every model's reasoning — not just the score
What you get in the app. 3 free AI predictions every week — no sign-up. Pro unlocks unlimited predictions and full performance insights.
Explore AI analysis in the app
the app
Frequently asked
▸Who is more likely to win, Everton or Newcastle?
Newcastle are the narrow lean. Everton are short of bodies, with Branthwaite, Grealish and Mykolenko doubtful, and their attack has been blunt. Newcastle have promised a strong XI and carry more threat in transition, though their own defensive fragility keeps the margin thin and a draw very possible.
▸What is the predicted score for Everton vs Newcastle?
The averaged AI scoreline is Everton 1–2 Newcastle.
▸How does ScoreGPT make Carabao Cup predictions?
Multiple AI models independently analyze form, squads and match context for every covered Carabao Cup fixture. ScoreGPT compares their picks and grades every prediction publicly after the final whistle.
▸What do the AI models predict for Everton vs Newcastle?
The panel treats it as a near coin-flip over 90 minutes, with four of five models leaning Newcastle by small margins. The fixed result is a narrow away win, but a lot of weight sits on a level game, and one model backs Everton on Newcastle's shorter rest and rotation.
▸What are the key factors for Everton vs Newcastle?
Everton's thin, injury-hit squad and makeshift defence, their blunt recent attack, Newcastle committing a strong XI, and Newcastle's defensive volatility. Everton's home resilience under Moyes and possible set-piece threat keep it close, while Newcastle's better transitions make them the slight lean.
Recent Carabao Cup results — graded
For information and entertainment only.